figures/figure11-status-patterns-journal.svg, 12.0 KiB, SHA-256 8bd0969ce13117a1, written by build_figure11_journal.py in the same package. It is shown because the bytes on disk still hash to the value the manifest records. The figure in the manuscript is drawn by the authors from the same numbers.The numbers in this figure
299 rows from figureB_source_data.csv, read out of source_data.zip in the deposit. Not a copy: the page reads the archive a reader downloads, so the two cannot disagree. The filename carries the pipeline's figure number, which is not this figure's number; the archive's index states the binding.
The archive's digest: 3558736147e731a25c113309a5af49e534421701d97c1324ddf703aed3d45266
All 299 rows, 5 columns
The table scrolls inside its frame; the header stays in place.
Panelpanel | Entityentity | Metricmetric | Valuevalue | Assessment idassessment_id |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | Acipenser baerii | latest_category | withheld | 156718817 |
| A | Acipenser baerii | latest_assessment_year | 2022 | |
| A | Acipenser baerii | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Acipenser baerii | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Alopias vulpinus | latest_category | withheld | 212641186 |
| A | Alopias vulpinus | latest_assessment_year | 2022 | |
| A | Alopias vulpinus | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Alopias vulpinus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Asio flammeus | latest_category | withheld | 210503760 |
| A | Asio flammeus | latest_assessment_year | 2022 | |
| A | Asio flammeus | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Asio flammeus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Balaena mysticetus | latest_category | withheld | 221069826 |
| A | Balaena mysticetus | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Balaena mysticetus | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Balaena mysticetus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Balaenoptera acutorostrata | latest_category | withheld | 219011809 |
| A | Balaenoptera acutorostrata | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Balaenoptera acutorostrata | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Balaenoptera acutorostrata | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Balaenoptera borealis | latest_category | withheld | 221059418 |
| A | Balaenoptera borealis | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Balaenoptera borealis | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Balaenoptera borealis | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Balaenoptera musculus | latest_category | withheld | 221061186 |
| A | Balaenoptera musculus | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Balaenoptera musculus | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Balaenoptera musculus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Balaenoptera physalus | latest_category | withheld | 213291870 |
| A | Balaenoptera physalus | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Balaenoptera physalus | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Balaenoptera physalus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Berardius bairdii | latest_category | withheld | 50351457 |
| A | Berardius bairdii | latest_assessment_year | 2020 | |
| A | Berardius bairdii | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Berardius bairdii | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Branta hutchinsii | latest_category | withheld | 139214707 |
| A | Branta hutchinsii | latest_assessment_year | 2021 | |
| A | Branta hutchinsii | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Branta hutchinsii | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Branta ruficollis | latest_category | withheld | 154473642 |
| A | Branta ruficollis | latest_assessment_year | 2025 | |
| A | Branta ruficollis | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Branta ruficollis | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Bubo scandiacus | latest_category | withheld | 205475036 |
| A | Bubo scandiacus | latest_assessment_year | 2021 | |
| A | Bubo scandiacus | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Bubo scandiacus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Buteo lagopus | latest_category | withheld | 202640529 |
| A | Buteo lagopus | latest_assessment_year | 2021 | |
| A | Buteo lagopus | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Buteo lagopus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Cetorhinus maximus | latest_category | withheld | 194720078 |
| A | Cetorhinus maximus | latest_assessment_year | 2021 | |
| A | Cetorhinus maximus | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Cetorhinus maximus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Delphinapterus leucas | latest_category | withheld | 219012513 |
| A | Delphinapterus leucas | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Delphinapterus leucas | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Delphinapterus leucas | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Enhydra lutris | latest_category | withheld | 219377647 |
| A | Enhydra lutris | latest_assessment_year | 2021 | |
| A | Enhydra lutris | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Enhydra lutris | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Eschrichtius robustus | latest_category | withheld | 213296952 |
| A | Eschrichtius robustus | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Eschrichtius robustus | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Eschrichtius robustus | on_ordinal_scale | no | |
| A | Eubalaena glacialis | latest_category | withheld | 221073107 |
| A | Eubalaena glacialis | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Eubalaena glacialis | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Eubalaena glacialis | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Eubalaena japonica | latest_category | withheld | 50380694 |
| A | Eubalaena japonica | latest_assessment_year | 2018 | |
| A | Eubalaena japonica | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Eubalaena japonica | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Falco peregrinus | latest_category | withheld | 210513652 |
| A | Falco peregrinus | latest_assessment_year | 2022 | |
| A | Falco peregrinus | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Falco peregrinus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Falco rusticolus | latest_category | withheld | 206261845 |
| A | Falco rusticolus | latest_assessment_year | 2021 | |
| A | Falco rusticolus | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Falco rusticolus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Globicephala melas | latest_category | withheld | 213293843 |
| A | Globicephala melas | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Globicephala melas | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Globicephala melas | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Grus canadensis | latest_category | withheld | 188597759 |
| A | Grus canadensis | latest_assessment_year | 2021 | |
| A | Grus canadensis | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Grus canadensis | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Hyperoodon ampullatus | latest_category | withheld | 221058609 |
| A | Hyperoodon ampullatus | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Hyperoodon ampullatus | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Hyperoodon ampullatus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Lagenorhynchus acutus | latest_category | withheld | 219011226 |
| A | Lagenorhynchus acutus | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Lagenorhynchus acutus | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Lagenorhynchus acutus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Lagenorhynchus albirostris | latest_category | withheld | 219011385 |
| A | Lagenorhynchus albirostris | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Lagenorhynchus albirostris | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Lagenorhynchus albirostris | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Lamna nasus | latest_category | withheld | 500969 |
| A | Lamna nasus | latest_assessment_year | 2019 | |
| A | Lamna nasus | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Lamna nasus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Leucogeranus leucogeranus | latest_category | withheld | 134180990 |
| A | Leucogeranus leucogeranus | latest_assessment_year | 2018 | |
| A | Leucogeranus leucogeranus | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Leucogeranus leucogeranus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Lontra canadensis | latest_category | withheld | 164577078 |
| A | Lontra canadensis | latest_assessment_year | 2021 | |
| A | Lontra canadensis | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Lontra canadensis | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Lynx canadensis | latest_category | withheld | 275326314 |
| A | Lynx canadensis | latest_assessment_year | 2025 | |
| A | Lynx canadensis | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Lynx canadensis | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Megaptera novaeangliae | latest_category | withheld | 219002308 |
| A | Megaptera novaeangliae | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Megaptera novaeangliae | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Megaptera novaeangliae | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Mesoplodon stejnegeri | latest_category | withheld | 50367496 |
| A | Mesoplodon stejnegeri | latest_assessment_year | 2020 | |
| A | Mesoplodon stejnegeri | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Mesoplodon stejnegeri | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Monodon monoceros | latest_category | withheld | 254246310 |
| A | Monodon monoceros | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Monodon monoceros | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Monodon monoceros | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Numenius borealis | latest_category | withheld | 178901365 |
| A | Numenius borealis | latest_assessment_year | 2021 | |
| A | Numenius borealis | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Numenius borealis | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Odobenus rosmarus | latest_category | withheld | 272356023 |
| A | Odobenus rosmarus | latest_assessment_year | 2025 | |
| A | Odobenus rosmarus | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Odobenus rosmarus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Orcinus orca | latest_category | withheld | 218567908 |
| A | Orcinus orca | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Orcinus orca | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Orcinus orca | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Phocoena phocoena | latest_category | withheld | 247632759 |
| A | Phocoena phocoena | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Phocoena phocoena | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Phocoena phocoena | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Phocoenoides dalli | latest_category | withheld | 50370912 |
| A | Phocoenoides dalli | latest_assessment_year | 2018 | |
| A | Phocoenoides dalli | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Phocoenoides dalli | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Phoebastria albatrus | latest_category | withheld | 132642113 |
| A | Phoebastria albatrus | latest_assessment_year | 2018 | |
| A | Phoebastria albatrus | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Phoebastria albatrus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Physeter macrocephalus | latest_category | withheld | 50382216 |
| A | Physeter macrocephalus | latest_assessment_year | 2025 | |
| A | Physeter macrocephalus | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Physeter macrocephalus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Rhodiola rosea | latest_category | withheld | 55685155 |
| A | Rhodiola rosea | latest_assessment_year | 2014 | |
| A | Rhodiola rosea | latest_assessment_scope | Global | |
| A | Rhodiola rosea | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Ursus maritimus | latest_category | withheld | 217912462 |
| A | Ursus maritimus | latest_assessment_year | 2025 | |
| A | Ursus maritimus | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Ursus maritimus | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| A | Ziphius cavirostris | latest_category | withheld | 219010340 |
| A | Ziphius cavirostris | latest_assessment_year | 2023 | |
| A | Ziphius cavirostris | latest_assessment_scope | Europe | |
| A | Ziphius cavirostris | on_ordinal_scale | yes | |
| B | Acipenser baerii | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 2 | |
| B | Alopias vulpinus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 2 | |
| B | Asio flammeus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 1 | |
| B | Balaena mysticetus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 1 | |
| B | Balaenoptera acutorostrata | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 1 | |
| B | Balaenoptera borealis | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 1 | |
| B | Balaenoptera musculus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 1 | |
| B | Balaenoptera physalus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 4 | |
| B | Berardius bairdii | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| B | Branta hutchinsii | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| B | Branta ruficollis | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 3 | |
| B | Bubo scandiacus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 3 | |
| B | Buteo lagopus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| B | Cetorhinus maximus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 1 | |
| B | Delphinapterus leucas | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 2 | |
| B | Enhydra lutris | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 1 | |
| B | Eschrichtius robustus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| B | Eubalaena glacialis | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 2 | |
| B | Eubalaena japonica | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| B | Falco peregrinus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| B | Falco rusticolus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 1 | |
| B | Globicephala melas | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| B | Grus canadensis | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| B | Hyperoodon ampullatus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 1 | |
| B | Lagenorhynchus acutus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| B | Lagenorhynchus albirostris | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| B | Lamna nasus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 4 | |
| B | Leucogeranus leucogeranus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 1 | |
| B | Lontra canadensis | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| B | Lynx canadensis | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| B | Megaptera novaeangliae | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 1 | |
| B | Mesoplodon stejnegeri | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| B | Monodon monoceros | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 2 | |
| B | Numenius borealis | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| B | Odobenus rosmarus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 2 | |
| B | Orcinus orca | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| B | Phocoena phocoena | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 1 | |
| B | Phocoenoides dalli | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 1 | |
| B | Phoebastria albatrus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 1 | |
| B | Physeter macrocephalus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 2 | |
| B | Rhodiola rosea | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| B | Ursus maritimus | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 1 | |
| B | Ziphius cavirostris | category_transitions_1982_2025 | 0 | |
| C | 1996 | species_assessed | 34 | |
| C | 1996 | high_risk_en_cr | 7 | |
| C | 1996 | high_risk_share_pct | 20.6 | |
| C | 1997 | species_assessed | 34 | |
| C | 1997 | high_risk_en_cr | 7 | |
| C | 1997 | high_risk_share_pct | 20.6 | |
| C | 1998 | species_assessed | 34 | |
| C | 1998 | high_risk_en_cr | 7 | |
| C | 1998 | high_risk_share_pct | 20.6 | |
| C | 1999 | species_assessed | 34 | |
| C | 1999 | high_risk_en_cr | 7 | |
| C | 1999 | high_risk_share_pct | 20.6 | |
| C | 2000 | species_assessed | 35 | |
| C | 2000 | high_risk_en_cr | 7 | |
| C | 2000 | high_risk_share_pct | 20.0 | |
| C | 2001 | species_assessed | 35 | |
| C | 2001 | high_risk_en_cr | 7 | |
| C | 2001 | high_risk_share_pct | 20.0 | |
| C | 2002 | species_assessed | 35 | |
| C | 2002 | high_risk_en_cr | 7 | |
| C | 2002 | high_risk_share_pct | 20.0 | |
| C | 2003 | species_assessed | 35 | |
| C | 2003 | high_risk_en_cr | 7 | |
| C | 2003 | high_risk_share_pct | 20.0 | |
| C | 2004 | species_assessed | 35 | |
| C | 2004 | high_risk_en_cr | 7 | |
| C | 2004 | high_risk_share_pct | 20.0 | |
| C | 2005 | species_assessed | 35 | |
| C | 2005 | high_risk_en_cr | 7 | |
| C | 2005 | high_risk_share_pct | 20.0 | |
| C | 2006 | species_assessed | 36 | |
| C | 2006 | high_risk_en_cr | 7 | |
| C | 2006 | high_risk_share_pct | 19.4 | |
| C | 2007 | species_assessed | 37 | |
| C | 2007 | high_risk_en_cr | 8 | |
| C | 2007 | high_risk_share_pct | 21.6 | |
| C | 2008 | species_assessed | 39 | |
| C | 2008 | high_risk_en_cr | 9 | |
| C | 2008 | high_risk_share_pct | 23.1 | |
| C | 2009 | species_assessed | 40 | |
| C | 2009 | high_risk_en_cr | 9 | |
| C | 2009 | high_risk_share_pct | 22.5 | |
| C | 2010 | species_assessed | 40 | |
| C | 2010 | high_risk_en_cr | 10 | |
| C | 2010 | high_risk_share_pct | 25.0 | |
| C | 2011 | species_assessed | 40 | |
| C | 2011 | high_risk_en_cr | 10 | |
| C | 2011 | high_risk_share_pct | 25.0 | |
| C | 2012 | species_assessed | 40 | |
| C | 2012 | high_risk_en_cr | 11 | |
| C | 2012 | high_risk_share_pct | 27.5 | |
| C | 2013 | species_assessed | 40 | |
| C | 2013 | high_risk_en_cr | 11 | |
| C | 2013 | high_risk_share_pct | 27.5 | |
| C | 2014 | species_assessed | 42 | |
| C | 2014 | high_risk_en_cr | 11 | |
| C | 2014 | high_risk_share_pct | 26.2 | |
| C | 2015 | species_assessed | 42 | |
| C | 2015 | high_risk_en_cr | 13 | |
| C | 2015 | high_risk_share_pct | 31.0 | |
| C | 2016 | species_assessed | 42 | |
| C | 2016 | high_risk_en_cr | 13 | |
| C | 2016 | high_risk_share_pct | 31.0 | |
| C | 2017 | species_assessed | 42 | |
| C | 2017 | high_risk_en_cr | 13 | |
| C | 2017 | high_risk_share_pct | 31.0 | |
| C | 2018 | species_assessed | 42 | |
| C | 2018 | high_risk_en_cr | 12 | |
| C | 2018 | high_risk_share_pct | 28.6 | |
| C | 2019 | species_assessed | 42 | |
| C | 2019 | high_risk_en_cr | 9 | |
| C | 2019 | high_risk_share_pct | 21.4 | |
| C | 2020 | species_assessed | 43 | |
| C | 2020 | high_risk_en_cr | 9 | |
| C | 2020 | high_risk_share_pct | 20.9 | |
| C | 2021 | species_assessed | 43 | |
| C | 2021 | high_risk_en_cr | 9 | |
| C | 2021 | high_risk_share_pct | 20.9 | |
| C | 2022 | species_assessed | 43 | |
| C | 2022 | high_risk_en_cr | 9 | |
| C | 2022 | high_risk_share_pct | 20.9 | |
| C | 2023 | species_assessed | 43 | |
| C | 2023 | high_risk_en_cr | 7 | |
| C | 2023 | high_risk_share_pct | 16.3 |
Cells marked withheld are IUCN categories this deposit may not redistribute; REBUILD-IUCN.md in the deposit rebuilds them from the IUCN's own release.
Binding derived
status-patterns · pipeline artifact figureB · binding proposed, unconfirmed
Binding evidence, as the record states it: figureB_source_data.csv carries the three panels in long form, computed from the global-and-European series the lead author decided on 21 October 2026: Global and Europe assessments form one series per species, ordered by year and assessment id, the higher id standing in a year with several, and only the one assessment that is regional but not European (the Mediterranean Lamna nasus 2016, 16527805) is left out; the seven European assessments the record files without a scope (species_data/curated/iucn_scope_corrections.csv) count, as European. Panel A gives the latest assessment of either scope, with its scope in the latest_assessment_scope rows: 4 CR, 3 EN, 11 VU, 3 NT and 21 LC, and one Regionally Extinct. Panel B's per-species transition counts sum to 43. Panel C, comparable assessments only, reproduces 7 EN or CR species of 34 in 1996, 13 of 42 in 2015 to 2017, 9 of 42 in 2019 and 7 of 43 in 2023; the number of assessed species grows from 5 in 1988 to 43 in 2023. response/check_figure11_source_data.py compares every value with the authors' table, response/from-tom-2026-10-21/skuggi/Figure-11-source-data-all-panels.csv.
No named person has checked that pipeline artifact figureB is the code that produced this manuscript figure. The evidence for the proposal is stated below. The four fields that follow describe figureB. If the binding is wrong, they describe the wrong figure, and that possibility is disclosed here rather than absorbed.
Evidence: figureB_source_data.csv carries the three panels in long form, computed from the global-and-European series the lead author decided on 21 October 2026: Global and Europe assessments form one series per species, ordered by year and assessment id, the higher id standing in a year with several, and only the one assessment that is regional but not European (the Mediterranean Lamna nasus 2016, 16527805) is left out; the seven European assessments the record files without a scope (species_data/curated/iucn_scope_corrections.csv) count, as European. Panel A gives the latest assessment of either scope, with its scope in the latest_assessment_scope rows: 4 CR, 3 EN, 11 VU, 3 NT and 21 LC, and one Regionally Extinct. Panel B's per-species transition counts sum to 43. Panel C, comparable assessments only, reproduces 7 EN or CR species of 34 in 1996, 13 of 42 in 2015 to 2017, 9 of 42 in 2019 and 7 of 43 in 2023; the number of assessed species grows from 5 in 1988 to 43 in 2023. response/check_figure11_source_data.py compares every value with the authors' table, response/from-tom-2026-10-21/skuggi/Figure-11-source-data-all-panels.csv.
Confirming this requires the person who produced the figures.
1. Data inputs derived
Computed from the figure pipeline's declared tables and query.
- Database schema
arctic_v2- Tables
- Database release
- IUCN Red List snapshot 2026-07-22
- Extraction date
- 22 July 2026
- Redistributable
- No. IUCN Red List terms do not permit redistribution of the categories. The assessment identifiers and the rebuild route are deposited instead; this table carries counts, not categories.
2. Processing steps derived
Each step is a path in the figure pipeline's own repository, which this site does not host. Regenerate and verify commands are literal. 1 of the 2 artifacts below is served here, and carries a download link; the rest are named so the chain can be read, not followed.
- Read the frozen intermediate.
data/processed/iucn_historic_timeline.json - Compute and write the frozen numeric source data.
visualizations/source_data/figureB_source_data.csv, download
3. LLM involvement: none
No generative model participated in producing this figure. The generator imports only csv, json, sys, collections, pathlib and the project's redlist_scale module, which is the one Red List scale and holds no model call either. No model API is called at any step, and there is no prompt because there is no model.
This is asserted mechanically rather than by declaration. visualizations/tests/test_no_model_calls.py reads this manifest, opens every script and generator it names, searches for model SDKs and API clients, and fails if it finds one. It covers every script and generator the manifest names.
The generative model in this project drafted 343 narrative prose sections about the 43 species. None of that prose reaches any figure, and none of it is displayed on this site: it is withheld pending expert review.
No review has begun, so there is no agreement statistic to report and no page reporting one. What can be checked is that the withholding is complete: the drafts are deposited unrendered as supplementary/species_narratives_no_citations.csv, every species page states how many of its sections are withheld, and the dataset page marks the table as unreviewed content.
4. Validation
Automated gate: passed. Byte-exact regeneration from the live database against the frozen source data.
Human review: generated 2026-10-06; no named person has signed the binding and it is not yet independently confirmed. withheld The automated gate establishes that the numbers are reproducible from the database. It establishes nothing about whether they are the right numbers to plot. That judgement requires a person, and no person has recorded it.
Known defects, one.
Figure 10's caption says the assessed-species count grows from 5 in 1988 to 42 in 2023. 5 in 1988 is exact; 42 is the 2014-2019 value and the count is 43 from 2020, when Mesoplodon stejnegeri gains the single comparable global assessment Section 4.4 reports in its own words. Held as: the generator asserts 43 and refuses to reproduce the caption's figure; the manuscript carries a margin query for the authors.